The Aim of Punishment
Task 1
There are several different punishments that can be given out in the UK.
Can you name any?
Answers
Fines
ASBO
Prison
Community Service
Tagging
Purpose of Punishment
There are several different reasons for the punishments we give out across the world.
More specifically there are four main reasons why.
Deterrence
Make the punishment so bad everybody would be too scared to do the 'bad' action.
Reform
Making changes to make a person 'better'.
Retribution
Punishment given out as a form of revenge for the victim/ victims' family.
Protection
Keep society and people safe by keeping 'bad' people away from them.
Task 2
Have a read over the different UK punishments.
Which purposes do you think match up to the punishments?
UK Punishments
Fines
ASBO
Prison
Community Service
Tagging
Purpose of punishment
Reform
Protection
Retribution
Deterrence
Task 3
Read over the below crime scenarios.
Make a note of the Scenario number.
Write beside each number:
-
What UK punishment do you think should be given? e.g. community service.
-
Why did you give this sentencing? e.g. payback to the community for damaging it
-
What is the purpose of this punishment? e.g. Protection/reform.
Crime Scenario 2
Accidentally killing someone during a fight.
Crime Scenario 3
Breaking into a pensioners house and stealing.
Crime Scenario 4
Adjusting your taxes so you do not give the government so much money.
Crime Scenario 1
Parking on double yellow lines.
Crime Scenario 5
Drink driving (no deaths or accidents).
Crime Scenario 6
Rape.
Crime Scenario 7
Child Abuse.
Crime Scenario 8
Drug Dealing.
Task 4
Read over the reflective questions below and answer them.
REMEMBER to include at least one detailed reason for your answer.
OPTIONAL: Challenge question
Question 1
Question 1
Do you think punishment should involve revenge?
Question 2
Question 2
Do you think we should give serious offenders, e.g. child abusers, the chance to change?
Question 3
Question 3
Do we need to execute murderers to protect ourselves?
Challenge
Question 1
Challenge
Question 1
Should executions be an acceptable form of revenge in Scotland?
Give at least 2 reasons for your answer
Challenge
Question 2
Challenge
Question 2
What could the potential drawbacks to having the death penalty in Scotland be?
Challenge
Question 3
Challenge
Question 3
Why might people think the death penalty is a good deterrent?